Middle East Facts Weblog中東事實博客

Was the “Massacre” of Qana Staged?是"大屠殺"的卡納上演？

Preliminary IDF investigation of the bombing of civilians in Qana has found some oddities in the timing of events occuring on the night of the civilian building collapse killing scores of Lebanese civilians.以色列國防軍的初步調查轟炸平民在卡納發現一些奇特，在時機的事件發生當晚，民用建築物倒塌造成數十名黎巴嫩平民。 Brigadier General Amir Eshel, Head of the Air Force Headquarters of the IDF, claims that the collapse of the civilian building in Qana fell eight hours after being struck by Israeli missiles.準將阿米爾eshel ，團長，空軍總部，以色列國防軍聲稱崩潰的平民建築在卡納下跌8個小時後，被擊中了以色列導彈。 This eight hour gap, of course, would be plenty of time for the residents to vacate.這八小時的差距，當然，將有充裕的時間，為居民必須遷出。

Eshel told journalists: “the attack on the structure in the Qana village took place between midnight and one in the morning. eshel告訴記者說： "這次襲擊對結構中的卡納村之間發生在午夜時分，其中一個是在早上。 The gap between the timing of the collapse of the building and the time of the strike on it is unclear.” The building collapsed at 8:00 AM and according to Eshel and the head of the IDF’s Operational Branch, Major General Gadi Eisnkot, no IDF action was concentrated on the building at that time.差距的時機倒塌的大樓及時間的罷工目前還不清楚" 。大廈坍塌於上午08時00分，並根據eshel及主管的以色列國防軍的業務科，少將gadi eisnkot ，沒有國防軍的行動，則集中於建立在那個時間。

If it turns out that Hezbollah fabricated this “massacre”, we shouldn’t be surprised.如果最後證明真主黨編造這個"大屠殺"的時候，我們不應該感到驚訝。 It’s just another example of terrorist groups playing on Western and Arab sensitivities to turn the tide in their favour.它的另一範例，恐怖集團在玩西方和阿拉伯敏感問題，以扭轉對他們有利。 Let’s hope they’re discovered for the monsters that they are.讓我們期待他們發現，為怪獸說，他們的影響。

For more information, please see如需更多資訊，請參閱 YNET news新聞的消息 and及 Confederate Yankee邦聯楊基 . 。

8 Responses to “Was the “Massacre” of Qana Staged?”八反應" ，是"屠殺"卡納上演" ？

1. Delia Says: 利亞說：
   August 8th, 2006 at 11:16 am 2006年8月8日，在上午11時16分

   Notice I have yet to hear one mother, one wife, one father, one son, one anyone say……..I’m, realted to a Hezbollah fighter.通知，我還沒有聽到一個母親，一個妻子，一個父親，一個兒子，其中一個人說… … ..我， realted到一個真主黨戰士。
   So where are the people related to Hezbollah living?所以人都到哪裡去了有關真主黨的生活？
   That is my point, if you are related to the Hezbollah then what do you expect?這是我的一點，如果你是關係到真主黨那麼，你有什麼期望？

2. Steve Says: 史蒂夫說：
   August 12th, 2006 at 3:32 pm 2006年8月12日在下午3點32分

   It’s true Delia, we don’t hear anybody admit it.它的真實利亞，我們並沒有聽到任何人承認。 Unless all these Hezbollah guys are unmarried, which is highly unlikely, their wive’s support them and act as human shields for them.除非所有這些真主黨傢伙都未婚，這是極不可能的，其wive的支持，並充當人肉盾牌給他們。

3. jd Says: 聯合聲明說：
   August 18th, 2006 at 5:38 am 2006年8月18日在上午05時38分

   Wow.哇。 I try to be a moderate Arab, but when I see this, I just don’t understand how it is so easy for you to ridiculize the death of innocent arabs.我嘗試是一個溫和的阿拉伯國家，但是當我看到這個，我只是不明白它是如何使您輕鬆ridiculize死亡的無辜的阿拉伯人。 Now the only reaction for atrocities is to blame in on the people who were subjected to it, and deny its existence !現在唯一的反應暴行，是推卸責任，對人民，他們受到了它，並否認它的存在！ What does it matter what happened in this particular event and what this reporter did when we know 800 people died at least for no reason, no victory an any side.它的內涵是什麼事發生在這個特別的事件和這個記者的時候，我們知道， 800人死亡，至少沒有理由，沒有勝利，是一個任何方面。 do yourself a favour and watch : Peace, Propaganda and the Promised land, and see that the news you r watching are making you the monster that you are, e.g.做自己的忙，看：和平，宣傳，並應許之地，看到這個消息，你r看著正在你怪你，例如： “if you are related to the Hezbollah then what do you expect?” "如果你是關係到真主黨那麼，你有什麼期望？ "

4. Sam Says: 薩姆說：
   August 24th, 2006 at 10:21 pm 2006年8月24日在下午10時21分

   what difference does it make besides think about it do u really think israeli aircrafts cant take out a building with 3 hits?有什麼區別，它使此外去想它做u真的認為以色列飛機斜面拿出大樓3訪問？ if israel could take out tunnels bridges and roads with one aerial shot, you dont think they can take out a single building with 3?如果以色列可以採取走出隧道，橋樑和道路，與一個空中開槍，你不用覺得他們能拿出一個單一的建設同3嗎？ besides israel said they wuold suspend there airsrikes for 48 hours because of the qana hits but israel attacked with airstrikes long before the 48 hours were up除了以色列說，他們wuold暫停有airsrikes 48小時，因為卡納訪問，但以色列攻擊的空襲行動早在48小時內上漲了

5. Truth Says: 真理說：
   August 29th, 2006 at 11:13 pm 2006年8月29日在下午11時13分

   Also, a French nurse was watching the vids of the wreckage and noticed that all the kids have something different about the post-mortum stances: They are all mentally handicapped kids.此外，一名法國護士看著Vids我的殘骸，並發現所有的孩子們也有不同的約後mortum態度：他們都是弱智的孩子。 She believes that the Hezbollah blew the building in the guise of the Israli attack to get rid of their weak and helpless kids.她認為，如果真主黨犧牲的建設中的花樣翻新的israli攻擊，以擺脫自己的軟弱和無助的孩子。
   http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http://www.france-echos.com/ac tualite.php?cle=9800 http://translate.google.com/translate?u=http://www.france-echos.com/ac tualite.php ？ cle = 9800

6. marc Says: 馬克說：
   September 15th, 2006 at 6:56 pm 2006年9月15日在下午6時56分

   Umm just because the IDF sais the qana massacre was staged it must be true?烏姆蓋斯爾只是因為以色列國防軍高等卡納屠殺是上演了它必須真實嗎？ even though every other country opposes this accusation?即使所有其他國家反對這一指責？

   so according to your logic iran is rght for saying the holocaust never happened.所以按你的邏輯，伊朗是rght說納粹大屠殺從未發生過。

   Think about it for a moment.想想這一個時刻。

7. Helen Says: 海倫說：
   September 16th, 2006 at 6:49 am 2006年9月16日在上午06時49分

   To jd:以聯合聲明：
   You say you are a “moderate arab”, does that mean that you kill only by lethal injection instead of the “fervent arab” be-heading by sword?你說你是一個"溫和的阿拉伯國家" ，這是否意味你殺了，只有注射毒針不是"熱切地阿拉伯" -標題劍？
   Please explain, thank you!請解釋一下，謝謝！

8. Haz Says: 哈茲說：
   September 16th, 2006 at 5:57 pm 2006年9月16日在下午5時57分

   “Now the only reaction for atrocities is to blame in on the people who were subjected to it, and deny its existence” "現在唯一的反應暴行，是推卸責任，對人民，他們受到了它，並否認它的存在" 。

   I never understood the evil that jewish people say or do.我從來不理解邪惡的猶太人說或做的。 Not after the holocaust.不要在大屠殺之後。 the persecution of palestinians by those that were persecuted beggars belief.迫害巴勒斯坦人，由那些被迫害乞丐的信念。 I understand now that you’re media has turned most of you into monsters.據我所知，現在，您再也媒體已經把大部分的，你變成怪物。 The truth is that neither hisbollah nor hamas pose any real threat to israel.事實的真相是，既不hisbollah也不是哈馬斯造成任何真正的威脅以色列。 Israel created Israel and hamas in order to justify to the world their greed and monstrosities.以色列創造了以色列和哈馬斯為了證明給世界，他們的貪婪和monstrosities 。 Hmas are just palestinians that grew tired of seeing their mothers and sisters slaughterd by american supplied israeli planes.皇家海軍只是巴勒斯坦人長大厭倦看到他們的母親和姐妹slaughterd由美國供應以色列飛機。 unfortunately they have no effective weapons to defend themselves, so in tehir desparation and anger they kill a couple of citizens.不幸的是，它們都沒有有效的武器，為自己辯護，所以在tehir desparation和憤怒，他們殺害一對夫婦的公民。 No real threat to israel.沒有真正威脅到以色列。 But Israel knew that they would do this.但以色列也知道他們會做到這一點。 why else would they have murdered children and innocents, and stolen their farms and homes?否則為什麼他們殺害兒童及無辜，並偷去其農場和家園？ If they keep their own jewish citizens afraid of these ‘terrorists’ then the jews are always going to vote for the most brutal and greedy leaders.如果他們保持自己的猶太公民怕這些'恐怖分子' ，然後猶太人總是要投給最殘暴和貪婪的領袖。 Look at Gaza.看看加沙。 They pulled those ‘poor jews’ from their homes and put them in condo’s with waterfountaines, but they did it so brutally with their army.他們退出這些'窮人猶太人從各自的家中，把他們的公寓的同waterfountaines ，但他們這樣做，是如此殘暴與他們的軍隊。 this gave the message to sympathetic jews that this could be you next.這使得信息同情猶太人，這可能是你未來。 no more withdrawal requests by empathetic jews to worry about.沒有更多的提款申請，由同情猶太人的後顧之憂。 then we find out the real reason why the jews were pulled out of gaza.然後，我們找出真正的原因為何猶太人撤出加沙。 so that Israel could deal out effective terror.使以色列能處理出有效的恐怖。 they couldnt cut off all electricity, food and water to gaza when their own jews lived there.他們couldnt切斷所有電力，食物和水，到加沙時，他們自己的猶太人住在這裡。 The poor israeli army were finding it difficult to kill a lot of palestinians with minimum effort when they are scattered around like that.窮人以色列軍隊發現難以殺害了很多巴勒斯坦人與最低工作時，他們散佈在這樣的。 Anyway my point is that jews have to see beyond this disgraceful propaganda by their own people.反正我的意思是，猶太人要看看以後的這種不光彩的宣傳，由他們自己的人民。 The bigger and bolder the lie the more likely that people will believe it.更大和更大膽的謊言，越有可能有人會相信這一點。 i have so much love and cried so much when i watched jews standing up against Israels atrocities and recognising that they are dishounering their ancestors that were murdered and persecuted.我有這麼多的愛與哭了這麼多的時候，我看了猶太人站起來反對israels暴行，並認識到他們是dishounering他們的祖先被殺害和迫害。 they did not go through all that so that jews can do the same to other innocent children.他們沒有經過一切，讓猶太人可以做同樣的，以其他無辜的兒童。 we are all God’s children and God will punish those that kill cheat and manipulate, especially in his name or under some belief that they are chosen and better than others.我們都是上帝的兒女，上帝將懲罰那些殺人，欺騙和操縱，尤其是在他的名字，或根據某些信仰，他們所選擇的，並優於他人。 Make love not war.做愛不要戰爭。

Feedback反饋